Cayuga Lake Vineyards: Best Wineries near Cayuga Lake

Tucked into New York’s scenic Finger Lakes region, Cayuga Lake isn’t just a destination for nature lovers and boaters—it’s also one of the finest wine regions in the eastern United States. The area around the lake is home to the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, America’s first organized wine trail, which winds its way along the shoreline, linking some of the most charming, innovative, and award-winning wineries in the state.

Whether you’re a seasoned wine connoisseur or a curious traveler looking for a glass with a view, the wineries near Cayuga Lake offer more than just tastings. They blend scenic vineyards with warm hospitality, lakeside sunsets, and wines that express the terroir of this glacially carved landscape.

Here’s a look at some of the best wineries to visit near Cayuga Lake.

1. Sheldrake Point Winery

Perched on the western shore of Cayuga Lake, Sheldrake Point Winery is one of the most celebrated names in the region. The vineyard overlooks the lake, offering a serene and elegant setting that pairs beautifully with its wines. Known especially for its Riesling and Ice Wine, Sheldrake Point has received national recognition for both its red and white varietals.

The winery is set on a former orchard, and today it includes 60 acres of vines, a tasting room, and an art gallery. Visitors often enjoy their tastings on the lakeview patio, especially in summer and early fall when the vineyard is lush and green.

2. Buttonwood Grove Winery

Located in Romulus on the western lakeshore, Buttonwood Grove Winery is a favorite stop for those traveling the wine trail with a bit of extra time. The winery combines high-quality wines with a relaxed, rustic charm. Their Cabernet Franc and Chardonnay stand out, though they’re also known for creative blends.

In addition to tastings, Buttonwood offers live music events, food pairings, and even on-site cabin rentals for overnight stays. The panoramic view of Cayuga Lake from their tasting deck is reason enough to linger longer.

3. Thirsty Owl Wine Company

Just north of Sheldrake Point sits Thirsty Owl, a winery that manages to balance wide recognition with a personal, down-to-earth vibe. With over 150 acres of vines, it’s one of the larger producers on Cayuga Lake, and its wines—especially the Riesling, Pinot Noir, and Sauvignon Blanc—have won numerous awards.

The tasting room is open year-round and includes a bistro offering light fare, making it a great midday stop for wine and lunch. The lawn stretches right down to the lake, creating an idyllic setting for a picnic with a glass in hand.

4. Hosmer Winery

A hidden gem on the western shore, Hosmer Winery has a rich family farming history and a strong commitment to sustainable viticulture. It’s a must-visit for anyone interested in learning more about the craft of winemaking. Their Dry Riesling, Lemberger, and sparkling wines are consistently praised.

Hosmer offers both indoor and outdoor tasting areas, and its casual atmosphere makes it especially welcoming. The knowledgeable staff often guide guests through comparative tastings and talk about the region’s unique growing conditions.

5. Lucas Vineyards

Lucas Vineyards, the first winery to open on Cayuga Lake, has been a local favorite since 1980. Still family-owned and operated, the winery is best known for its Nautie wine series—a fun and fruity line of wines with playful labels—but also produces excellent varietals and dry styles.

The tasting room is lighthearted and friendly, with a strong community vibe. Many visitors return for seasonal events like grape stomps and craft fairs, which turn a simple wine stop into a full-day outing.

6. Long Point Winery

On the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake near Aurora, Long Point Winery offers a quieter and more intimate experience. Their wines include rich reds such as Merlot and Zinfandel, less commonly found in the Finger Lakes region. The tasting room looks out over rolling vineyards that slope down toward the lake, providing stunning views and a peaceful ambiance.

Long Point is ideal for visitors looking to avoid crowds and discover something a little off the beaten path while still enjoying top-quality wine.

7. Treleaven Wines

Located in King Ferry on the lake’s eastern side, Treleaven Wines combines handcrafted winemaking with a laid-back social atmosphere. The winery produces a variety of wines, from crisp whites to bold reds, and is especially known for its unoaked Chardonnay and Cabernet Franc.

Treleaven’s outdoor event space, “The Hangtime,” hosts regular food trucks, concerts, and seasonal gatherings. It’s a popular hangout spot for both locals and visitors, especially in the warmer months.

8. Heart & Hands Wine Company

A boutique winery on the northeastern side of the lake, Heart & Hands is dedicated to producing small-lot, handcrafted wines. Their focus is on Pinot Noir, grown in their estate vineyards and sourced from select Finger Lakes growers. Their minimalist approach allows the character of the grape and the site to shine through.

Because of their small size, tastings are typically conducted by appointment, offering a personal and in-depth experience. For wine lovers looking for an elevated and thoughtful tasting, this is a must-visit.

Final Thoughts

Cayuga Lake isn’t just a scenic retreat—it’s a place where tradition, innovation, and terroir come together to produce some of the finest wines in New York. Whether you're spending a day following the wine trail or making a weekend out of vineyard visits, each winery offers its own unique blend of flavor, hospitality, and setting.

From lakeside patios to rustic barns, dry Rieslings to barrel-aged reds, the wineries near Cayuga Lake offer more than wine — they offer a taste of the region’s soul.